Hi people,
Been thinking about possible table talk topics as I think we were beginning to discuss a couple of weeks ago what we might do. A few for us to think about doing or not as the case may be with some facilitated from the 'outside'and some from within ourselves:
Homosexuality and the Bible
Feminist/Liberation/Black/Post colonial theology
Bible - Word of God?
Science and faith (Joe Baker)
Faith in a post modern world (Gordon Lynch?)
What does it mean to be green? (John Scrivner)
Politics and faith (Jonathon Bartley)
Islam - get a Muslim in to talk about their faith etc
Psychology/sociology of religion - is religion just what we construct?
Comparative religion - do they all say the same thing? (From someone who is a John Hick type of theologian)
Not sure it is a table talk but some form of life journeying journalling together - deepen our relationships and all that. Ria could perhaps help in putting that together?
Tim
Thanks for putting these together, Tim. All look like very interesting topics.
There's also a list of topics available here, a few of which we've done now.
Personally I'd like to do something on Gender and Identity next, connected in some ways to this discussion. But we ought to decide together what we take on next.
Also I think we're starting to get overdue with some time to talk over as a community where we're at with Table Talk in general - how it's working for us, what's not working, what could be done better, structure, involement/participation of everyone in the discussions, etc.
I for one am particularly alarmed that - and I'm aware that is a generalisation - at most of the discussions the dominant voices are male, and the women, in general, don't participate much. And I know that frequently many people feel that the discussions are flying over their heads, which I think is a big problem. If that is the experience of a sizeable number of people in the community, which I think it is, I don't think Table Talk is working for the community as it ought to/could do - it may well be working for some be people, but if others are feeling alienated then it's a problem we need to talk over together, I'd say.
What I'm saying is that I think we need a time before the next Table Talk, and probably before we decide the topic for the next one, to all sit down together and assess where we're at with Table Talk.
I think it's always good to assess where we're at with stuff we're doing and I also think that table talk is obviously really working for some people. My feeling is that we just need to make sure that as a community we are doing all kinds of things so that everyone is able to participate fully in the type of setting they feel most comfortable in. There will always be those who contribute more and those who like to sit back and listen, we just need to make sure that everyone feels they are listened to when and if they have things they wish to contribute. Maybe a Thursday night session to brainstorm other settings would be really helpful?
[..listenin'n'learnin different sprawls of effects and impacts and landscapes and landscopes and journals and journeys ...]
Table Talk means?....that: someones gonna speak who's that ? an' someone's gonna listen who's that ? shouldn't it be the other way round? Usually I find myself far more interested in who hasn't said anything or very little.. not in what the cognitive value but what the being value... I fill in the gaps shouldn't ? should I .. am I afraid of the silence ? do we measure others by our own fear of pauses hesitancy?
it seems that Table Talk happens in Birmingham.. is that right?... if so is there the possibility of some form of basic ... place to put a sleeping bag... (asking not as a demand but polite enquiry .. a friendly church porch would do ..?) I'm assuming that I'm not the only interested party that would have to travel quite far to participate (though probably not on a regular basis)
is it possible to do meet up on a topic led basis and chat on line? just an option.. I prefer the live setting personally...
I take Sarah's comments as valid about folks needing to get or feel comfortable... as well as Joe's... there will always be those who wade right in to talk regardless of setting and company and those who will hesitate... in a sense, that something is happening is the main thing... the interrupters and those who don't turn up are as valid to a discussion of inclusivity as the management thereof... but whilst you can pray and do your best as intentions in the end .... the horse doesn't have to drink.... even if we are all willing it to.... I am reminded of the notion of the dove in the crevice in the Songs of Solomon... for all the remonstrating and ... plans for it from outrside ..it's not going to come out unless it has to, is forced to or is listened to? listening is as important a part of participation as oratory... and in the silence..... we learn to hear...
it is not true that those absent or those silent aren't participating...
if they/we? feel alienated then are we/they? listening to them/us? the stories brought... to be heard spoke that GOD wants us to hear?there are so mnay ways to learn?... some through speaking some through listening for the speakers let them not be confined to their methods (they are not the only ones and they are not the only methods of learning for them too,) there; for the listeners they too....speaking in a universal method?...plurality?
when we feel we are the only ones to share then it is time for us to listen humility eat humble pie sometimes it is for us to share to speak but not alone cos we are used to this arena this role
something on my mind from Workshop and from church is the notion... that doing something that is designed for all inclusivity eg something that is an all comers response thing eg creative... that gives space to sharing from all... eg the doodler on the table cloth a sharing of expression allcomers allabilities WELCOME!
ACTUALLY... this is more about listening learning to relate to folks we don't always do to or bother to... inclusivity is : cos we want to hear all... cos we learn to listen to hear all... I have no illusions about how hard this task is it involves as much about listening to our own untold unheard stories.... listening to ... our enemies and those we don't relate to or want to relate to as well as our friends.. (our friends? aren't they the ones who listen to us?..)
some of us expect to be listened to regardless some never to be listened to regardless it's part of a socialisation thing that doesn't have to be gender distributed there are many men who wouldn't dare speak as well as many women who just won't shut up... but! if a man joins a women's table does he expect them to fit in with him ? if a woman joins a men's table does she expect to fit in with them? stereotyping? do we want to carry on without interruption or do we secretly and desperately welcome the interruption and wonder why they haven't said anything?
as someone who seems to be in the middle of things in the noise wherever I go
The topic
summarising the scope and thread online can carry on ideas and discussion of sorts..
I believe in all inclusivity (I don't pretend I'm much good at it ... all of or even some of the time.. but I do value it...) we have so much to learn above all it's a process of learning... each event is separate distinctive in it's preparation? it's happening? who is it for? what is it for?.... is there Divine Inspirement somewhere in the being of the event is it a discussion? is it community is it church? is it friends etcetcetc any event is organised is all those things and more
learning about our expectations and ourselves is as much part of that journey
reflection is good .. in real life the journeys and conversations and learning go on and on elsewhere regardless ...
GOD BLESS!
Peace and Love,
I had a little bit of a splutter (a small one!) with my smile scanning Tim's list
(I confess!!! and hope that does not offend! .........that I....read:)
Feminist/Liberation/Black/Post colonial theology ..???!!
...was a little intriguedby .. that :? all the girls might be lumped in with miscellaneous(butnotall) distantly oppressed boys(and girls) as a suitable topic for one evening! was intrigued with the similarities ? probably... or possibly even...? is there one or many liberation Theology(WORD OF GOD)
GOD BLESS!
Peace and Love!
Recent comments